Against The Tide

Song:Against The Tide
Animes: the obvious ones, hunter x hunter and fate stay night

Oh the YouTube editing. It really amazes me that people still edits like this.

I'm sorry to say, but that was pretty horrible and too quick to be an amv. Make one at least 1:20, 2 min or so before posting on here.

Please make a presentation and GL on your next as well.

The 3d movement and text was completely unnecessary and messy, the length just makes it worst, its obvious you know techniques but don't know how to use them properly but you're from a different community so its understandable that you edit differently from us I guess.

Kisagi wrote:Oh the YouTube editing. It really amazes me that people still edits like this.

I'm sorry to say, but that was pretty horrible and too quick to be an amv. Make one at least 1:20, 2 min or so before posting on here.

Please make a presentation and GL on your next as well.

lemme say this first this way of editing is cool and many others like this way. Anyway are you trolling me? because i know what a horrible amv is and this isn't one of them "too quick to be an amv" im sorry did god give you a time frame of whats considered an AnimeMusicVideo? i didn't see in this topic rules that an AnimeMusicVideo had to be at least 1:20 anywhere so forgive me if i don't if i make my video how i want however long i want okay amv expert?

Not my cup of tea, most of the time it was messy with the strong blurs,3d stuff, text. Blurs could be much more softer its too strong and I'd say the text font is a bit too plain and doesn't go well imo. Some mask placements could be better like 0:15 (also there is a big difference in lighting for that mask try to make masks match scenes more) and towards the end it loses some momentum (Slower)

vipertrix wrote:Not my cup of tea, most of the time it was messy with the strong blurs,3d stuff, text. Blurs could be much more softer its too strong and I'd say the text font is a bit too plain and doesn't go well imo. Some mask placements could be better like 0:15 (also there is a big difference in lighting for that mask try to make masks match scenes more) and towards the end it loses some momentum (Slower)

thanks for your opinion man much appreciated i will try to do better next time  

Well I've never heard of a 20 second music video. An AMV is just a music video using anime as the source for the video.  It's not considered finished if you start midway through the song and it ends abruptly.

Knight wrote:Well I've never heard of a 20 second music video. An AMV is just a music video using anime as the source for the video.  It's not considered finished if you start midway through the song and it ends abruptly.

its a mep part.

That just means its not an AMV lol

Well my answer was given

Spoiler:

hmm.. I don't mean any disrespect but I think the youtube community shouldn't refer to forums unless they acknowledge the way things are run here.

995Gabber wrote:

Spoiler:

hmm.. I don't mean any disrespect but I think the youtube community shouldn't refer to forums unless they acknowledge the way things are run here.

Well I wouldn't say that. People have to learn sooner or later on what's actually good in an Amv and what the word means.